Anyone who writes, as a profession or a hobby, knows that over-all perception of erotica authors is poor and no where is this belief held more firmly than within the writing community. "They're not real writers," other they say (or type). It's not just that we dare to write about sex (or even profit from it) but if we write about it, it must be because we "can't really write" and this is our last resort.
Anyone who writes erotica (dirty stories, erotic literature, porn -- whatever you choose to call it) will tell you that writing smut takes extra skill. For not only must you obey all the rules of writing but you must make it arousing too. Just trying to find synonyms for "cock" (without sounding cliched) and "orgasm" (virtually non-existent) is a challenge. But 'the real writers' will giggle and sneer. I've seen the cruelty in writer's groups and online forums firsthand.
Even mainstream editors and publications may reject your work on these very notions, or just from the fear of any association. Even for non-fiction works this happens. Mention you write 'about sex' in any fashion (or have them discover you do so) and you're blackballed. So in order to preserve my professional mainstream writing reputation, I created a pen name upon joining the ranks of smut writers.
You'd think that a group which has experienced such persecution and unfair devaluation would be wiser. But they are not.
Once confronted with the 'bad thing' I'd done, and feeling that no good would come of admitting one job since it would put another at risk (not to mention these people live where I do and know my face, car etc.), I set about convincing them that I was merely suggesting the work to this woman and that she had drawn the wrong conclusions. (Since the old agency assigned names, I had no connection for anyone to trace and prove differently.)
However the rest of that meeting was completely consumed by a discussion about whether or not I should have ever even made such a suggestion -- and if they should draft group guidelines to specifically prohibit phone sex workers from joining the group.
:sigh:
There were two issues discussed -- or accusations thrown -- here.
First was the matter of "ethics". How could anyone profit from selling herself? How degrading! How cheap!
I asked how dirty stories spoken on the phone were any worse than written dirty stories; both have the same purpose, both are forms of adult entertainment. That question was met with a more silence and sputtering than actual answers or even argument. Still, I felt I'd made no impression. At least not a positive one. They moved onto the other issue.
The second issue was that of "writing quality". Clearly 'some girl who just talked dirty' shouldn't fancy herself a writer; letting her join was to 'add to her delusions'. I tried to argue that one skill or job did not automatically cancel-out the other; that the writing should speak for itself.
This is not to say that all PSOs are excellent writers, or writers at all. (They may have the creativity, but not the writing skills.) Nor is every erotica author able to deliver great phone sex. (Not all authors can be so creative as to think up stories on the fly, let alone tailor them for pleasing a specific individual.) But to assume that any decent author is suddenly less able to write because they talk dirty on the phone for pay makes about as much sense as it does to say an author's ability &/or talent decreases with every sex-themed work they write.
So once again I needed a new pen name in order to protect my status as an erotica author. Go figure.
And so this is why I am unable to fulfill your requests to see my other published works. And this is why you might just be surprised to discover that other PSOs have many other hidden talents they keep mum about.



5 comments:
"I've seen the cruelty in writer's groups and online forums firsthand."
I can imagine. And in my opinion -- as a writer of smut, comedy, drama, fact, and other non-smut related stuff -- it's a big old case of (written) penis envy.
In other words, i know what you mean. That said, I've admitted in my real life, to people who have read my other writings and know that i can string two words together successfully that i also write erotica. Some are interested and want to know where (I never show them), and some are just ineterested. I've never experienced the prejudice and snobbery of which you speak, although i do not doubt that you are right and it exists. I suppose it depends on the audience.
Either way -- all power to your elbow. And all your other pointy bits.
As a full-time freelance writer, I think that writing erotica is even more challenging than writing other forms of fiction or non-fiction. Like you said, there are only so many non-giggle-inducing words for cock.
I hope that someday we won't need these silly pen names. Sigh.
And I think that it's great your a pso. If you like doing it and make good money, why not?
In a way your experiences just serve to highlight the power of good writing about sex. It arouses people's puritanical zeal because they are scared to admit it arouses other bits of them.
Holy cow... I can't believe this actually happened to you. Actually, I can, and I just wish it didn't. The writing community can indeed be a completely snobbish, judgmental, and cliquey one... like any, I suppose.
Entertainment is entertainment. Creativity is creativity. And one artist is just as much a creator of art as another. One of these days, those close-minded of our creative community might finally realize that judging another's art isn't really the act of an artist at all.
Kudos to you for telling this tale, hopefully broadening more minds because of it, and continuing to be yourself in this close-minded world.
xoxo
Tara
Thank you all for your support -- it really means much :)
I'm off to poke about all your blogs now!
Post a Comment